Jesus' Resurrection - Were The Apostles Deceived?

By: Rob VandeWeghe

The lives of the twelve Apostles as well as those of Paul and James provide clear evidence they were convinced Jesus really returned from the dead, but perhaps they were deceived. They believed it to be true, but had they been fooled?

Over the centuries there have been several variations of this notion, usually known as the swoon theory. All have been abandoned or died a quiet death. The general idea is that Jesus survived the cross and was later revived. His appearances to the disciples were therefore not miraculous, as he never died in the first place.

The theory comes in different flavors, some include:

• The Passover Plot (1965). According to its author, Hugh Schonfield, Jesus was a deceiver who carefully plotted His career as Israel’s Messiah. Working closely with accomplices Lazarus and Joseph of Arimathea, He planned His survival of the cross. While on the cross, Joseph arranged to have Jesus given a drink to appear dead. On Saturday, Jesus was then removed from the grave and revived.

• The Jesus Scroll (1964). Donovan Joyce in 1964 asserted to have been told of a now lost scroll that might have been written by Jesus at the age of 80. He suggests that Jesus never died on the cross, but plotted with the guards, that after being drugged He was pronounced dead. In the tomb, a doctor, assisted by Joseph of Arimathea (Jesus’ uncle) nursed Jesus back to health. As Jesus recovered, He paid one last visit to His disciples and then lived as a monk at Qumran. Jesus married Mary Magdalene, fathered at least one son, and fought the Roman army at Masada, where He died.

• Holy Blood, Holy Grail (1982). This account claims that Jesus was drugged to make Him appear dead. Pilate was bribed to the body’s removal from the cross alive. The Essenes (yes, they are part of this as well) then laid His body in the grave of Joseph of Arimathea (a relative of Jesus). Jesus revived and went to France, together with His secret wife Mary Magdalene (remember, this book also inspired Dan Brown’s The DaVinci Code), Joseph and Lazarus (Jesus’ brother-in-law). There, Jesus and Mary’s children start a secret royal bloodline.

These accounts are a great illustration of Occam’s razor. How many more wild fantasies have to be invented to explain away the facts? How much better does the resurrection fit the events? The swoon accounts all assume that Jesus was administered some kind of drug to make Him look dead, and a number of unlikely accomplices helped him escape death and revive in the tomb. However, how wild are these speculations? Even with these speculative props, how could Jesus fool the other people at the crucifixion? How could He convince the Jews and Roman soldiers that He was dead when only drugged? And lastly, even for a moment, suppose He swooned, think about the shape Jesus would have been in. He was flogged and had been nailed to a cross for several hours. Even if still alive, Jesus would have been in desperate need of serious medical help. If He would have appeared to the disciples in this shape, they would have not believed for a second this was a glorious resurrection, instead they would have immediately realized that somehow Jesus had survived the crucifixion and needed immediate medical attention.

Article Source: http://www.bigfreearticles.com

The lives of the twelve Apostles as well as those of Paul and James provide clear evidence they were convinced Jesus really returned from the dead, but perhaps they were deceived They believed it to be true, but had they been fooled

About the Author:
Rob VandeWeghe is a sceptic turned Christian. Rob’s book ‘Prepared to Answer’ and more evidences for Christianity are available at http://www.WindmillMinistries.org. more about Jesus’ resurrection

Tags: religion, apologetics, resurrection, crucifixion, jesus of nazareth, swoon theory, passover plot, davinci code

Please Rate this Article

Comments

Share This Article - Quick and Easy Using This Button:

Click the XML Icon Above to Receive Religion Articles Via RSS!

Read More Articles From - Home | Religion

Is Self-Esteem Contrary To Christianity By: Johnny Kicklighter - The philosophy of self-esteem is probably the most influential doctrine to arrive on the scene in Christendom's recent history. At least in my lifetime, it has had as much affect, if not even more, on evangelical Christianity than the modern tongues movement that surfaced in the late 1960's. Not only has self-esteem psychology crept into every aspect of Biblical doctrine and practice but society as well.
Tags: religion, self esteem, biblical counseling, christian, iabc, nanc, self-esteem
The New Basis For Hope By: Julie Redstone - A new energy is in the air. It is the energy of magic and of hope, of new possibilities and new learnings that come in ways unforeseen. The arrival of the new is based on the infusion of spiritual light onto the physical plane, enabling those who have been asleep for years or lifetimes to awaken now to themselves, to each other, to the heart of the universe.
Tags: religion, hope, spiritual awakening, new hope
Book Review: Jay Adams's Competent To Counsel By: Johnny Kicklighter - It wasn't until the early 1970's when I was introduced to Jay Adams that I begin to see a great distinction between generic counseling and genuine biblical counseling. I was 21 years old at the time when the pastor of our new formed church bought and read Adam's book "Competent to Counsel." My pastor raved on the significance of the book and proceeded to indoctrinate our small flock with its contents.
Tags: religion, biblical counseling, christian, iabc, nanc, psychology, problems
Book Review: Jesus Christ: Self-Denial Or Self-Esteem By Dr. David Tyler By: Johnny Kicklighter - If one didn’t look at the title of Dr. Tyler’s book, “Jesus Christ: Self-Denial or Self-Esteem,” they might think they were reading a book about the life of Christ instead of a refutation of the self-esteem movement. Dr. Tyler takes a different approach that’s characteristic of some of the other books on critiquing self-esteem. He doesn’t exclusively argue that the self-esteem position is defective from a humanistic psychological approach as Paul Vitz does.
Tags: religion, landscaping, landscape, mowing, lawn care, flowers, retaining self-esteem
Jesse Tree and Advent Bridge Path From Past to the Future By: Elizabeth Guide - The Jesse Tree is the perfect complement to Advent. Its is a great way to recall history of Jesus and his family as well as applying it to the four weeks of advent that are highlighted with the four advent candles on the advent wreath. The Old Testament prophet Isaiah said that the messiah will spring from the roots of Jesse, with the famous Jesse being David’s father.
Tags: religion, advent wreath, christmas decor, holiday decor, home decor
Religious Home Decor is a Show of Faith By: Elizabeth Guide - They say your house says a lot about you. For Christians, much of the décor of their home may reflect their beliefs. As you look around your friends homes you can get a feel for where Christ or their religious belief fits in their life.
Tags: religion, home decor, religious home decor
Blending the Jesse Tree and Advent Wreath By: Elizabeth Guide - The Jesse Tree and Advent wreath are two very common items Christians have used to mark four week period before Christmas called Advent or the six period that was known as Celtic Advent. In the modern time Advent has become a great way to stay focused on Christ and helping families overcome the commercial hurdles that Christmas represent. The Jesse Tree is an older customer that was the precursor to the Christmas tree.
Tags: religion, advent wreath, christmas decor, holiday decor, home decor
You Can’t Out-Give God By: Lynn Powers - After nearly five years of trying and two miscarriages, I was pregnant. Our entire family was elated! But we already had two teen boys and money was tight. I prayed fervently that God would supply our needs. Soon after I began praying, my parents came to visit. Mom held out an envelope and said, “Grandma sent this for you.” My grandmother?
Tags: religion, christian, christian devotional, daily devotional, bible devotional, devotions, giving
Our Evolution And The Deeksha Oneness Blessing By: Chava LeBarton - There is a new phenomenon moving throughout the world on nearly every continent known as Oneness Deeksha or Oneness Blessing. It is a transfer of energy that pierces through the veils and illusions of the mind, bringing about deep stillness and peace. This Blessing is given by people who have undergone a 21-day process in India at the Oneness University ( http://www.onenessuniversity.org ) and have been initiated as Oneness Blessing Givers.
Tags: religion, abundance, deeksha, oneness blessing, divine grace, energy transfer, oneness
Physical Reality and Our Knowledge By: Sarah Martin - We have decided that knowledge of the physical world is just the tested propositions achieved by the intelligent use of the data of observation. These propositions are referred to the physical world as their object of judgment. We come to the decision that physical things have size, exclude one another, are massive, have structure and organization, have capacities for action, and behave in certain describable ways.
Tags: religion, sample petition, citizen petition, petition letters, perception, object, knowledge