The “Oracle” And The Intoxilyzer: DWI/DUI Source Code Defense

By: Maury D. Beaulier

In the Kingdom of Nod, a villager’s fate hangs in the balance as wise men huddle around the oracle. The oracle will decide his fate. The penalties exacted may be severe: freedom or servitude; the forfeiture of his worldly possessions; the payment of punitive tariffs; or a prohibition against travel. But the Oracle is all seeing and all knowing, able neatly discern guilt or innocence from only a puff of the villager’s breath. Its’ extraordinary powers belie its unremarkable visage. Dark, square and mysterious, its inner workings were unknown to all except the wizard that presented it to the Kingdom. Wizard Seeim Eye promised that the oracle used powerful magic unrivaled in all of the world. It was, based on those pronouncements, that the King decreed the oracle faultless and its pronunciations absolute.

Given a cue, the villager puffs upon the oracle. Lights dance across its façade and its magic is clear to see. Within moments, its mysterious evaluation has concluded and its decision presented on a scroll to the wise men at its periphery. “Guilty.” No further questions need be asked as the villager is escorted from the room to await his sentencing.

The legal system in the Kingdom of Nod sounds pretty frightful, doesn’t it? While it may seem like a fanciful story, the paragraph above describes precisely how our own legal system works in it treatment of DWI/DUI cases. The cases often hinge on our own modern day “oracle”, the Intoxilyzer 5000. The Intoxilyzer 5000 is manufactured by its own wizard, a company called CMI, Inc. Its makers promise that the machine is, in fact, accurate. It is based on that assessment that States enacted legislation or had defining case law determine that the results of the intoxilyzer 5000 must be presumed accurate. In Wisconsin the Intoxilyzer 5000 is an approved method of testing pursuant to § 343.305(6)(b), Stats., and Wis. Adm. Code § Trans 311.04, and it is generally afforded a presumption of accuracy and reliability, see State v. Disch,, 119 Wis.2d 461, 475, 351 N.W.2d 492, 499 (1984); State v. Busch , 217 Wis.2d 429, 442-43, 576 N.W.2d 904, 909 (1998); In Minnesota, the intoxilyzer 5000 is presumed reliable if the proper procedure was used in running the test. State v. Dille, 258 N.W.2d 565, 567 (Minn. 1977) (citations omitted); see Tate v. Comm’r of Pub. Safety, 356 N.W.2d 766, 767-68 (Minn. App. 1984). This essentially shifts the burden of proof in a DWI/DUI case from the state to the driver to prove that the Intoxilyzer 5000 is in error. It is for that reason that many states having ongoing DWI/DUI litigation related to the source code of the Intoxilyzer 5000.

Before the source code, can be discussed, a brief and simplistic explanation of our “oracle” - the Intoxilyzer 5000 - is necessary. The Intoxilyzer 5000 is a machine with a complex set of functions. It is a computerized system that has a tube attached on one end for receiving breath samples, and a printer attached to the other end to record results. A driver breathes into the tube, the sample swirls around inside a chamber in the box, and the printer then displays the test results. Presumably what occurs is that the machine accepts a sample of air from a user and chambers that air. It then beams infrared light through the holding chambers where sensors on the other side of the chamber determine how much absorption of certain waves of infrared light has occurred. Based on that data, an analysis is made to determine the amount of alcohol contained in the sample to absorb that amount of light. Further mathematical calculations are done to determine the amount of alcohol in the underlying tissues in the lungs with respect to the determination of the amount of alcohol in the alveolar air.

The “source code, a computer program, is a coded set of instructions that control every mechanical function of the intoxilyzer 5000. That is true whether it is an instruction to turn the machine on, make the fan operate, or to make analytical analysis such as the rate at which alcohol absorbs infrared light and the mathematical formula comparing alcohol content in alveolar (“deep lung”) air to the blood alcohol content in the tissues below. As a result, in order to understand the inner workings of the Intoxilyzer 5000, it is necessary to have a copy of the source code and to have it independently tested for accuracy.

As a direct result, in many states, Minnesota included, defense attorneys have filed Motions seeking to compel disclosure of the source code for the Intoxilyzer 5000. The state does not have access to the source code and, when it is requested from the manufacturer, CMI, they are told it is a trade secret and that it will not be provided. In other words, nobody actually knows what goes on inside this machine except those who have viewed (or written) the source code. Yet, under law, everyone in the legal system must assume that the result is accurate and, to a great degree, indisputable. In other words, the response by CMI is the equivalent of saying – “trust us, it works.” Unfortunately, when “trust” results in the guilt or innocence of citizens, it is not so easily given.

That is particularly true when every computer owner knows, machines are subject to failures. The failure could be because of an incorrect code, a corrupted code or even subject to human error or human mischief. In short, machines are not perfect and the humans that program them are not perfect. What is particularly vexing is that the Intoxilyzer 5000 uses a microchip that is likely much less sophisticated than the one being used by your home computer. The testing process for a breath sample by the Intoxilyzer is run by a Z80 Microprocessor that utilizes an EPROM for program memory and handles all operator commands and interface devices. Simply put, this is not cutting edge technology. The Z90 microprocessor predates the original IMB PC. In fact, it was used back in the day for the Atari video game Pong. Your remember “Pong,” a game with all the complexity of two paddles and an electronic ball to bounce between the two. (See, www(dot)pchistory(dot)org)

The argument that a driver must have access to the source code in order to effectively challenge the results of a breath test appear to be gaining steam. In Minnesota, the state itself has sued that manufacturer of the Intoxilyzer 5000, CMI, Inc., arguing that based on its contract with CMI the state is the actual owner of the source code copyright. In suing CMI, the state of Minnesota avers that it owns the intangible copyright to this source code and demands, inter alia, specific performance of its contract and its right to possess (and copy) a tangible version of the intangible, intellectual property that the state contracted and paid for. The issue regarding the disclosure of the Source code as part of a DWI/DUI case in Minnesota is proceeding to the State Supreme Court in the case of State v. Underdahl and will be heard later this year in 2008. Ultimately, the result may provided those accused of DWI offenses in that state with some ammunition to challenge the results of the modern day “oracle” - the intoxilyzer 5000. Until the matter is decided, Motions seeking to compel disclosure of the source code or suppress the breath test result, remain an important and viable part of the DWI defense arsenal. Such motions should be considered in each case.

Article Source: http://www.bigfreearticles.com

In 2008, DWI/DUI challenges to the breath test, now, more than ever, have become viable and important. The latest challenges involve attacks on the source code, and the state’s failure to provide that computer source code for testing. In each case, a source code motion should be considered.

About the Author:
Attorney Maury D. Beaulier is recognized as a leader in DWI and criminal defense in Minnesota and Wisconsin. A frequent lecturer on defense issues, Mr. Beauler can be reached from his website at www.dwicounsel.com where you may Ask-A-Lawyer your DWI questions online or seek a FREE case review.

Tags: business, customer service, dwi, dui, dwi lawyers, dui lawyers, dwi attorneys, dui attorneys, source code breath test, intoxylizer source code, minnesota lawyer, dwi defense

Please Rate this Article

Comments

Share This Article - Quick and Easy Using This Button:

Click the XML Icon Above to Receive Customer Service Articles Via RSS!

Read More Articles From - Home | Business | Customer service

How We Do Windows-cleaning By: sally - Glass cleaning tips from Glass Doctor WACO, Texas (Nov. 19, 2008) – It’s more confusing than difficult to clean glass. Here are a lot of cleaning products on the market that promise to make window cleaning quick and easy.
Tags: business, customer service, glassdoctor, glassware, window panes, windows, glassservices
The Importance of choosing the right translation company By: agency41 agency41 - The Importance of choosing the right translation company Selecting the proper translation company is essential for any business concern to make profits. It is quite natural for a site owner to be ignorant about a foreign language in which he needs the content to be translated.
Tags: business, customer service, translation company, translation agency, translation service, professional translation, website translation
Know About Plumbing Services By: Eric the Plumber - Know how to get the best plumber A home must have a proper drainage system or in other words a proper circulation of water is very much needed. If there is some thing wrong then a professional is required to handle the problem.
Tags: business, customer service, plumber in los angeles, ca, los angeles plumbing service, los angeles plumbers, water heater
Troubleshooting Hydraulic Equipment By: Gordon Gordon - How to find your Hydraulic Specialist? The first thing that you should do when you install hydraulic equipment is to find a local hydraulic specialist and have him in your files so that you can get in touch with him as soon as something goes wrong.
Tags: business, customer service, hydraulic, pneumatic, hydraulic specialist, pneumatic specialist, hydraulic cylinder
Facts About Skip Hire By: Dan Fishern - Skip Hire Solutions For You One of the important considerations for home improvement is to plan ahead. To go about it, one has to make some simple decisions that many people do not consider important. One of the best examples of planning ahead is Skip hire service.
Tags: business, customer service, skip hire, skip hire london, skip hire birmingham, skips skip hire prices, skip hire uk.
HolidayMasti Unlimited Discount– It’s Raining Holidays By: santosh kumar yadav - The Sizzling summer is over and it's time to celebrate the magic of monsoon which evokes different feelings in different peoples. Despite the monsoon, or because of it, HolidayMasti Unlimited Discount plan their holidays in the winter season. It makes sense with so many discount offers.
Tags: business, customer service, holidays in india, hotels in india, holidaymasti unlimited, himalaya tour package
Pick an excellent carpet cleaning company By: daisy duke - Selecting a good carpet cleaning company Did that chit of a child from your neighbors threw out on the silk curtains of yours? Or did an infant wet your mattress? The purpose can be any, but the need to get the curtains, carpets, mattresses, rugs etc cleaned is inevitable.
Tags: business, customer service, carpet, upholstery, cleaning, cleaners, exeter
Different types of pest control method By: Jonathan15 Johnson15 - Different types of pest control method Pests like cockroaches, flies, ants, fleas, termites etc either in bedrooms or kitchens, can be highly disturbing. Though most of the people know their source but they falter in the effective use of pest repellents.
Tags: business, customer service, pest control, termite control, bed bugs, commercial pest control
Know More about the Building Courses By: Trent04 Trent04 - All About Continuing Professional Development Course The real estate industry is evolving at a rapid pace that has made it necessary for the real estate professionals to keep themselves abreast with the latest knowledge in construction courses.
Tags: business, customer service, building courses, courses in building
Multiple Business Offshoots Provided by Corporate Leasing Sydney By: Stewart20 Nichols20 - Leasing Company Australia Provides Incentives to the Commercial Corporations Summary: Vendor finance Sydney aids small and medium enterprises for concentrating on aspects that can lead to increase in their internal credit and commercial policies. This can help in reducing the cost behind processing and financing.
Tags: business, customer service, vendor finance sydney, business leasing sydney, leasing company australia, corporate leasing sydney, computer leasing australia